Avengers vs. X-Men “battlebooks”
Posted By onefinemess on January 15, 2012
So all the covers are up, and some of them are a bit confusing. I’d almost think I’m too old to weigh in on stuff like this – but these would have been some deep questions when I was 12, so I guess inner 12 year old me has something to say. Let’s just go down the list. Note that I’m assuming no prep-time. Prep-time would give certain people a huge advantage (Beast, Black Widow, Hawkeye maybe, Rogue).
![]()
![]()
Wolverine vs. Captain America : Haven’t we seen this before? Shouldn’t the archetypal pairing be Cyclops vs. Captain America? I guess maybe the outcome of that match would be too apparent? (Cap, unless Cyclops caught him full on with his guard down or something). So, I guess this is the “main event”. Even, I guess. Except that Wolverine will keep getting better, but I suppose Cap could get him down for a bit.
Storm vs. Thor : I love Storm to death, but there’s no way she should win this fight. It’s almost silly. They probably should have done Collosonaut vs. Thor – that’s really the closest thing to an even match I can think of for Thor, and he’d probably still win that one.
![]()
![]()
Spider-Woman vs. Gambit : The match no one cares about! No? Well, OK. This one is even enough then.
Spider-Man vs. Iceman : The money dictates that Spider-Man win (that and he always wins) but, realistically…Iceman could just freeze the whole room. Done, end of story.
![]()
![]()
Captain Marvel vs. Rogue : This one at least has some history to not. Not that I’m convinced any of this crap will make any sense – although Marvel swears it will – but there’s at least a back story here. Still, unless Carol is an idiot and lets Rogue get close, this isn’t even a fight. Seriously.
Psylocke vs. Black Widow : With prep time, the Widow would win. But I can’t see how that would happen in an actual fight.
![]()
![]()
Luke Cage vs Beast : Sorry Beast, this would last as long as it takes for him to hit you. I’m guessing there will be a lot of talking in this one.
Magneto vs. Iron Man : Except for the fact that Magneto is generally a villain, this should never be a fight. (Unless either party gets prep-time, of course).
![]()
![]()
Hulk vs. White Queen : OK. This is uh, interesting. Hulk’s gonna win that fist fight, so this is going to have to move onto the psychic level, where she’s got a chance. But, if that’s the case… I dunno, this is the only not like vs like match out of the covers. I’m confused. Then again, the Avengers have the Hulk + Thor (for this series at least) – what the hell do you do against THAT? Namor, maybe. Since he’s an X-person now? Namor vs. Thing (see below) is another match that would actually make a lot of sense but that they miss.
Cyclops vs. Hawkeye : Should be Cyclops by a mile, but you know, ambushes and all so who knows.
.
![]()
![]()
Daredevil vs. Archangel : Umm. What? Are we out of continuity here? I don’t even…
Colossus vs. Thing : I think this one has happened before, and the win went to the Thing. But, you know, with Cytorrak’s powers on top of his own, this should be Colossus by a mile.
That being said, the premise for this series (or rather, for the main AvX series – this book is simply described as fleshing out the battles from that book, so it’s at least not even trying to be anything other than what it looks like) looks somewhat terrible, even with all the “work” they’ve done to make there be an actual reason for the two big cash co-err teams to do battle. STILL. There is something to be said for comics targeted at 7-14 year olds. I mean, we haven’t had anything like Marvel vs. DC in a while (Avengers vs. Justice League was the most recent that I can recall and they, of course, teamed up in the end – still, this could end that way : Everyone vs. Phoenix!). And the books do seemed to have stirred up quite a bit of internet debate (old school! x vs y! Who is the strongest!?), that’s probably a good thing for Marvel.
[Note: All images from CBR article here.]


















